Catan Expansion Packs Explained: What’s the Difference and Which one is Best?

All image credits:

Catan, once known as The Settlers of Catan, has taken the board game world by storm with its engaging blend of strategy and luck. But what if you could add a new dimension to your gameplay? That’s where expansion packs come in.

These add-ons introduce new rules, strategies, and challenges to the classic game, offering a fresh and exciting experience. With several options to choose from, selecting the best one can be overwhelming.

In this post, we’ll explore the different Catan expansion packs, highlight their unique features, and help you find the perfect one for your next game night. Whether you’re a Catan novice or a seasoned veteran, this guide promises to enhance your gaming adventure.

“The Seafarers”

Catan Seafarers expansion pack

“The Seafarers” expansion enriches Catan with new components, including sea hexes, ships, and gold fields, bringing the nautical theme to life. Players can now venture into the high seas, exploring uncharted islands, trading with different cultures, and encountering pirate threats.

Key Gameplay Changes:

  1. Ships and Navigation: Players can build ships alongside roads to navigate between islands. Ships act as mobile roads on water and can be moved during the game.
  2. Discovery of New Lands: The game introduces scenarios that create undiscovered islands, leading to a dynamic and explorative gaming experience.
  3. Pirate Encounters: The pirate ship mechanic adds a layer of strategy and danger, as players must avoid or confront pirates on the open seas.
  4. Gold Fields: Gold fields allow players to choose resources of their choice, adding a unique tactical angle to resource collection.
  5. Scenarios and Varied Setups: With various scenarios and map configurations, “The Seafarers” offers diverse gameplay, enhancing replayability.

Target Audience and Playstyle:

Ideal for players who crave exploration and maritime adventure, “The Seafarers” brings a perfect balance of complexity and excitement.

Whether navigating treacherous waters or unearthing new lands, it offers something fresh for both newcomers and experienced players, without drastically altering the core mechanics of Catan.

Impact on Strategy:

The expansion encourages a broader strategic approach, as players must balance land and sea expansion, negotiate with pirates, and adapt to the ever-changing geography of the game board.

“Cities & Knights”

Catan Cities & Knights expansion pack

The “Cities & Knights” expansion transforms the urban development aspect of Catan, adding a layer of complexity and strategy. With new components like city walls, knights, and progress cards, it focuses on the defence and growth of cities, turning Catan into a more politically charged landscape.

Key Gameplay Changes:

  1. Development of Cities: Cities now have various improvement levels across areas such as trade, politics, and science. Investing in these areas leads to special benefits and progress cards.
  2. Knights and Barbarian Attacks: Players can recruit knights to protect their cities from barbarian invasions. Managing and upgrading knights becomes a critical part of the game.
  3. Progress Cards: Replacing development cards, progress cards offer more targeted and powerful abilities, providing new strategies and tactics.
  4. City Walls: Walls can be built to increase the hand limit size, protecting players from the robber and offering a more defensive play style.
  5. Commodity Resources: Three new commodities (paper, cloth, and coin) are introduced, enriching the trading aspect and adding depth to the economic system.

Target Audience and Playstyle:

“Cities & Knights” is designed for experienced Catan players looking for a more sophisticated and challenging game. It requires careful planning, strategic thinking, and a deeper understanding of the game’s mechanics. This expansion may not be suitable for beginners or those looking for a casual game night.

Impact on Strategy:

The addition of knights, barbarians, and city improvements creates a game where players must balance the growth of their cities with defence and economic management. Long-term strategic planning and adapting to opponents’ actions are key to success in this more demanding version of Catan.

“Traders & Barbarians”

Catan Trade & Barbarians expansion pack

The “Traders & Barbarians” expansion brings a collection of smaller expansions and scenarios, each introducing unique rules and gameplay twists. With components like wagons, bridges, barbarians, and camels, it adds a multifaceted experience to Catan.

Key Gameplay Changes:

  1. Varied Scenarios: Players can choose from different scenarios, each with specific rules and objectives, offering a fresh take on Catan in each game.
  2. Trading and Wagon Routes: Some scenarios introduce trading posts and wagons, allowing players to earn victory points by delivering goods, adding a logistics challenge.
  3. Fishermen and Rivers: Other scenarios include fishing grounds for more diverse resource collection and rivers that impose tolls, altering trading dynamics.
  4. Friendly Robber and Harbours: Adjustments to the robber’s rules and customisable harbour placements make for a more flexible and player-friendly experience.
  5. Bridges and Camels: New path-building options with bridges, along with camel-driven trading, enhance strategic positioning and connectivity on the board.

Target Audience and Playstyle:

“Traders & Barbarians” is perfect for those who want to continually explore new ways to play Catan. Its modular nature makes it adaptable to different player levels, preferences, and group dynamics. It’s a versatile expansion that can cater to both casual games and more challenging sessions.

Impact on Strategy:

The expansion’s variety encourages players to adapt to new rules and strategies with each scenario. From managing trading routes to capitalizing on fishing spots, the strategic depth is rich and multifaceted, allowing players to explore new dimensions of Catan without losing the essence of the base game.

“Explorers & Pirates”

Catan Explorers & Pirates expansion pack

“Explorers & Pirates” is an adventurous expansion that offers a blend of exploration, piracy, and discovery. With new components like ships, pirate lairs, fish, spices, and explorers, this expansion opens up a thrilling world of maritime adventure.

Key Gameplay Changes:

  1. Exploration and Discovery: Players embark on voyages to discover new lands, spices, and fish, with ever-changing map configurations for a unique exploration experience.
  2. Pirate Battles: Confront and defeat pirate lairs to earn rewards, adding an exciting combat dimension to the game.
  3. Fishing and Trading Spices: Fish and spices become new resources that can be traded and used to gain victory points, expanding economic strategies.
  4. Missions and Scenarios: A variety of missions and scenarios provide goals and challenges that guide players’ strategies and decisions.
  5. Ship Building and Movement: Ships can be built and moved across sea hexes, offering dynamic navigation options and interactions with other players.

Target Audience and Playstyle:

“Explorers & Pirates” appeals to adventurous players who want an immersive and story-driven experience. It’s best suited for those looking for complexity, thematic richness, and a focus on exploration and interaction. The expansion is more complex than the base game and might be overwhelming for new players.

Impact on Strategy:

The expansion significantly alters the core gameplay, encouraging exploration, risk-taking, and strategic planning. Managing resources, navigation, and combat with pirates requires a blend of tactical acumen and long-term strategy, offering a fresh and rewarding challenge for Catan enthusiasts.

Other Minor Expansions and Variants

In addition to the major expansions, Catan also offers several minor expansions, variants, and spin-offs that cater to various tastes and preferences.

“Helpers of Catan”

  • Description: Introduces helper characters with special abilities that assist players in different aspects of the game.
  • Ideal For: Those looking for individual player powers and added strategic choices.

“Frenemies of Catan”

  • Description: Encourages collaboration between players through mutual benefits and rewards for assisting others.
  • Ideal For: Players seeking a more cooperative and less confrontational experience.

“Oil Springs”

  • Description: Introduces oil as a new resource, along with environmental challenges and dilemmas.
  • Ideal For: Players interested in exploring environmental themes and ethical decision-making.

“Santa Claus” (Seasonal Variant)

  • Description: A festive-themed expansion with Santa Claus delivering gifts across Catan.
  • Ideal For: A light-hearted and festive game experience during the holiday season.

Spin-offs and Themed Editions

  • Description: Various themed editions such as “Star Trek Catan” and “Game of Thrones Catan” offer unique twists on the classic game, often with their own exclusive rules and components.
  • Ideal For: Fans of specific themes or franchises, or those looking to explore alternate takes on the classic Catan experience.

Which is the Best Catan Expansion pack for me?

Here are our recommendations, depending on what kind of player you are.

For Beginners

  • “The Seafarers”: A gentle introduction to expansions with engaging yet accessible gameplay.
  • “Traders & Barbarians” (Selected Scenarios): Some scenarios are beginner-friendly, offering fresh twists without overwhelming complexity.

For Experienced Players

  • “Cities & Knights”: A complex and strategic expansion that challenges seasoned Catan players.
  • “Explorers & Pirates”: Offers a rich and immersive experience for those who crave adventure and complexity.

For Thematic Players

  • “Explorers & Pirates”: Perfect for those who enjoy a strong narrative and adventurous themes.
  • Themed Editions and Spin-offs: Cater to specific interests and fanbases.

For Casual Gamers

  • “Seafarers”: Keeps close to the original game’s feel while adding enjoyable variations.
  • “Frenemies of Catan”: Encourages a more cooperative and light-hearted play experience.

For Environmentally Conscious Players

  • “Oil Springs”: Challenges players with environmental decisions and consequences.

Where Can I Buy Catan Expansion Packs From?

For individuals based in the US we would recommend purchasing direct from

For we would suggest purchasing from Amazon.

Leave a comment